Single Vendor Vs. Multi Vendor Marketplace: Which Model Is Ideal For HyperLocal Business?

By Matt Watson

August 10, 2021

Single Vendor Vs. Multi Vendor Marketplace: Which Model Is Ideal For HyperLocal Business?

Since its arrival in the market, E-commerce has been a hit. Thanks to the upcoming hyperlocal business models that have entirely redefined the economy. Their unstoppable popularity has pushed many startups to have a quick online presence and sell a whole set of services. Sellers in big numbers are now often turning online to expand business economically. The concept of making sales via marketplaces has become a hop-topic because of the utmost success they have. 

Now that you are on the road to starting your online business, there might be one confusion that comes across – Whether you sell products through a single vendor platform or multi vendor. For brick-and-mortar businesses, Single Vendor and Multi Vendor both are proving to be beneficial nowadays. They have become a powerful tool for brands looking to generate better revenues and a vast audience. A single vendor platform is the best fit for those who aim to open their own store, while multi vendor marketplaces are for companies who want to join an already established marketplace.

Integrating Your eCommerce Store Into Online Marketplace

Whether you need a solution from scratch or digitizing your existing offline operations, having an eCommerce platform is necessary for the current era. If you run a small business, it might be worth experimenting with a more straightforward and less expensive solution i.e. single vendor store that takes minimal setup and less coding knowledge. If your business processes are complicated, though, you’ll need a more robust and customizable solution – i.e. Multi vendor marketplace.

It can be challenging to pick which marketplace is ideal if you are new to the market. To assist you in making the wise selection, we have provided a detailed explanation on single vendor vs. multi vendor that will help you determine which the best fit is for your company.

Let’s Start From Introduction

Single Vendor Model

This model is typically for businesses who want their website and sell their own products. A single vendor store is one where only the owner sells his specific products. The owner is the only one who sells. Without your permission, no one else can sell your products. Here, the owner sells to his customers directly. In simple words, this model fits startups who want to sell their stock directly to their audience without using an intermediary. 

Impressive Features of Single Vendor Model

Limited range of items: A single vendor never meets all of its customers’ different wants, because it usually has a limited selection of products.

Enhanced order management system: When only one supplier is involved in selling products, it’s easy to integrate systems and place orders.

More Efficient Workflows: Coordination, supply, and communication are much easier with a single vendor model. It’s easy to communicate because you’re usually working with the participants of your own company. 

Easy entry into the market: Single vendors can readily enter the market because they are well known for their business and just need to get online.

FEWER LIMITATIONS TO SINGLE VENDOR STORE

Risk of an independent contractor  – When using a single vendor model, having only one contractor can be risky for a business.

Limited resources: Multi vendor marketplaces have the advantage of having third-party platforms, which doubles resources and makes business easy to grow. Single suppliers, on the other hand, do not have the same benefit.

Multi Vendor Marketplace

A multi vendor model completely differs from a single vendor model. It is an online store that sells products from multiple merchants. In this concept, sellers get together to sell their services or products through a shared store. As a result, a multi vendor marketplace is a system in which numerous merchants collaborate to show and sell their items with the help of a mediator, or you say, administrator.

Because of the numerous vendors involved in this model, there is an opportunity to make more significant profits. These marketplaces allow customers to buy products from various suppliers all under one roof, saving them time and effort. In this model, the vendor, the customer, and the administrator – all are engaged. The admin is in charge of the platform where these things are sold.

Impressive Features of Multi vendor Marketplace

Large-scale economy: A multi vendor marketplace has several vendors, resulting in multiple transactions every day. This enables the marketplace to profit from one or both of the sellers.

Increased product diversity: Selling products from numerous vendors offers more product variety. This eliminates the need for the platform to rely on a single vendor.

Best startup option: Small businesses may not have the same resources as giant corporations; thus, going with a single vendor model is not beneficial. The single vendor approach places a lot of responsibility and risk on the sellers, which a multi vendor model can eliminate. 

FEWER LIMITATIONS TO MULTI VENDOR MARKETPLACE

Administrative Concern– This business model necessitates the seamless integration of several stakeholders. Furthermore, several internet interfaces are involved, making it harder to troubleshoot activities of admins and their processes.

Integration Challenge – Because multiple teams build and manage distinct components of the product, making integration difficult. This concern can result in increased expenditures and effort for the company.

Higher expenses- When it comes to bargaining with different vendors, this model necessitates more significant expenditures.

For Customers: single vendor vs. multi vendor

When it comes to a single vendor platform, customers may consider connecting with only one supplier rather than many. The model makes it possible for businesses to decrease administrative costs and achieve reasonable pricing by making orders with just one supplier. On the other hand in multi vendor, there is always someone to fulfill the needs and rely back on if one of them fails.

For Owners: single vendor vs. multi vendor

Operating a multi vendor store is less risky than the single vendor store owner because you don’t adhere to just one niche but broaden your offering by bringing in other parties. Having many sellers in your website’s inventory lowers your financial risks significantly. However, it is challenging to oversee each seller in a multi vendor partnership and ensure that they supply high-quality goods. 

For Suppliers: single vendor vs. multi vendor

Suppliers benefit from a single marketplace. It reduces the time and expense of developing and deploying an ecommerce website, gives a cost-effective entry into the E-commerce landscape, and allows them to reach new markets and customers. In multi vendor, you will be subject to commissions and fees if you trade on a marketplace, which may make a long-term collaboration with the market.

SOME FACTORS TO CONSIDER – SINGLE VENDOR vs. MULTI VENDOR

Just after introducing the above marketplace, the time has come to differentiate these models based on some factors – Single Vendor vs. Multi Vendor Marketplace. Both of the previously stated models have their own set of benefits, limitations, and features. Option one may be better for one brand, while option two may be better for another. But still, the dilemma is going among many. We’ve outlined a few factors that help differentiate between the two and get you on the road to making an ideal decision.

THE TARGET OF YOUR BUSINESS: Those having a target of reaching a vast audience have to accept many risks that come with it. And here, the multi vendor marketplace proves beneficial as it offers excellent growth potential and better control over products and risks. On the other hand, establishing a single vendor platform is good if you want to take a low risk and have limited products for sale. 

THE COMPLEXITY: Single vendors, in comparison to multi vendor sites, usually offer a straightforward interface. In contrast, multi vendor marketplaces are complex due to the large number of products and merchants available. This also complicates product selection and adds to the number of steps required. A multi-store model must include variables such as location, store preference, and additional filters. 

THE DEVELOPMENT COST: Both the online marketplaces need specific investment when it comes to development and designing. But if you compare Single Vendor vs. Multi Vendor Marketplace, the pricing is going to be different. A multi vendor marketplace costs more than a basic single-store marketplace. The reason is the addition of advanced features and functionalities. You can consider the example of Etsy here; it has a more complex interface and multiple platforms under that further raise the costs.

IMPLEMENTATION: In this, all the challenges will be covered that one most likely to have when installing and configuring whichever system you choose. Considering single vendor store solutions, installing is often easier because there is only one set of programs/protocols to integrate into the existing systems. Whereas, the implementation is a little complex of the multi vendor solutions because there is a need to manage diverse technologies, which will typically take extra time to implement.

TRAFFIC VOLUME: Multi Vendor marketplaces will have a higher volume of traffic as compared to the single vendor model. Because of the many brands combined, the possibility is much higher to reach a broader audience. Simultaneously, a single vendor does not capture much traffic as one is solely running the business and has to put extreme effort to attract the audience. 

RETURN ON INVESTMENT: Because of no intermediaries in single store models, the seller receives the entire sale amount. In simple words, all profits go to the pockets of the single store owner. But in the case of multi vendor marketplace, the owners receive considerably lesser margin. They have to earn money through commissions, subscription fees, marketing fees, value-added advantages, and so on. 

TRANSACTION METHODS: Both the marketplaces or models necessitate the implementation of a payment mechanism. As the money is transmitted from the buyer to the vendor, the payment system of a single store can be simple. On the other hand, the marketplace comes with a more complex mechanism that permits money to be split between the parties and allows delivery people to collect their tips.

WHICH TO CHOOSE? SINGLE VENDOR vs. MULTI VENDOR

Both single vendor and multi vendor marketplaces hold importance at their own place. But if we talk about the present times, multi vendor marketplaces are dominating the single vendor stores. More and more entrepreneurs are considering opportunities in multi vendor marketplaces and at least in the single vendor website. Transforming business into a multi vendor marketplace ensures money flow is continuous and a minimal loss doesn’t affect the business. 

How to Get Started on a New Marketplace?

When it comes to starting your online store, you may need to look at what your competitors are up to. You could also want to compare your brand to what these models have to offer and align your needs with what works best for you. Hopefully, this whole post will help you make the ideal decision. 

You don’t need to consider thousands of aspects to building a viable and profitable marketplace from the ground up. Begin by considering the major factors that will determine the shape of your platform and how it will interact with the rest of the world. We at HyperLocal Cloud help transform your startup idea into a reality. Discuss your requirements today!

x
We use cookies to improve your experience on our site and introduce you to relevant content. To know more,privacy policy & cookie policy. Cancel Accept